Local and national news, NPR, things to do, food recommendations and guides to Los Angeles, Orange County and the Inland Empire
Stay Connected
Graphic of person's hand placing a ballot in a City of Los Angeles ballot box
(
LAist
)
LA City Council District 12
There are only two candidates in this San Fernando Valley race, so the March election winner will take the seat.
This story features Beeline Reader for enhanced readability. Click to turn the feature on or off. Learn more about this technology here.

If you live in the city of L.A., your city council member is probably the most powerful and important elected office you can vote for.

The makeup of the council determines what kind of laws might get passed that affect the entire city of L.A. How do you feel about issues like rent control? Building more housing? Transportation and pedestrian safety? Consider what solutions you’d like to see to these problems when thinking about which candidate to support.

What does L.A.’s city council do?

  • Create local laws, known as ordinances (the mayor then approves or vetoes those ordinances)
  • Order elections
  • Impose and regulate city taxes
  • Authorize public improvements
  • Approve city contracts
  • Adopt traffic regulations 
  • Vote on the mayor’s proposed budget 

If you want to know more about how the city council works and what decisions face the next council, head to our guide to the city council.

More Voter Guides

How to evaluate judges

  • L.A. Superior Court: There are more than two dozen judges up for election or reelection.
  • Judge ratings: Understanding how the L.A. County Bar Association evaluates judicial candidates — and how it can help you cast your vote.

Head to LAist's Voter Game Plan for guides to the rest of your ballot including:

  • L.A. County Board of Supervisors: Three of the five seats are on the ballot.
  • L.A. City Council: There are seven seats up for grabs.
  • L.A. District Attorney: Meet the 12 candidates running to be the county's prosecutor.
  • LAUSD: Four seats are open for a seat at the table.
  • Prop. 1: Here's a closer look at the proposal at the center of a debate over how to best help people struggling with mental health, drug and alcohol issues.

Fast facts on District 12

  • State of the race: Current council member John Lee is running for reelection. 
  • Number of candidates: 2
  • Where: San Fernando Valley, including Northridge, Chatsworth, Granada Hills, West Hills, Porter Ranch, Sherwood Forest, and portions of North Hills and Reseda
  • Key issues: Housing affordability, homelessness, environmental issues
  • Notable: District 12 is the largest city council district by geographic size. It’s been represented by Republicans for decades. Ethics is the central tension between incumbent John Lee and Serena Oberstein, the other candidate: the L.A. Ethics Commission recently accused Lee of accepting illegal gifts years ago as a Council staffer. Lee denies these claims. 
  • March outcome: Since there are only two candidates in this election, there will be no November runoff. Whoever gets more than 50% of the votes in the March election will win the seat outright. 

John S. Lee

City Councilmember/Father

Lee is the son of South Korean immigrants and served for many years as a City Council staffer for District 12. In 2019, he won a special election for the seat of city council member, replacing his former boss, Mitch Englander. He then won a full term in 2020. Lee was a registered Republican when he assumed the city council seat.

Lee’s predecessor, Englander, had faced several federal charges for allegedly accepting a cash payment and Las Vegas trip in 2017 from an entrepreneur who wanted his help in building relationships with downtown developers. Englander ultimately pleaded guilty to a single count of scheming to obstruct an FBI investigation, and was sentenced to 14 months in prison.

Lee was one of Englander’s staffers at the time and confirmed that he went on the Las Vegas trip, but was not charged with any crimes in the FBI investigation. He said he was “unaware of any illegal activities” that Englander had been charged for. However, in October 2023 the L.A. Ethics Commission formally accused Lee of accepting illegal gifts before and during that trip. Lee denies the allegations and has sued the Ethics Commission.

Platform highlights:

  • On housing affordability: Lee supports “rolling back the restrictions on small mom-and-pop property landlords.” In November 2023 he voted against the City Council’s move to allow rent increases of 4% to 6% in rent-controlled apartments. He had supported allowing higher rent increases, up to 7% to 9%. He supported the addition of about 300 temporary shelter beds for unhoused people in District 12 since coming into office. Lee also opposed an affordable housing proposal in Chatsworth funded by Proposition HHH, a $1.2 billion voter-approved bond, saying the size of the project was too big to fit with the surrounding community. 
  • On homelessness: Lee says making housing available is legally necessary for L.A. to address homelessness, but he supports services to “to address the root causes of homelessness, such as mental health and addiction.” He also enforced L.A.’s anti-camping ordinance more aggressively than any other district. 
  • On public safety: Lee says he voted “against all arbitrary ‘defund the police’ LAPD cuts and [is] committed to increasing the morale among our rank-and-file officers.” Lee was one of two city council members to vote against a proposal in 2020 to cut the LAPD’s budget by $150 million. 
  • On restoring public trust: He supports an independent redistricting process, similar to those at the county and state levels. 

Go deeper: Jump to Lee’s full answers to the LAist candidate survey

More voter resources:


Before you keep reading…
Dear voter, we're asking you to help us keep local election news widely available for all today. Your financial support allows our reporters to research candidates and provide you and your neighbors the tools you need to make informed decisions when casting your ballot. When reliable local election reporting is widely available, the entire community benefits. Thank you for investing in your neighborhood.

Serena Oberstein

Nonprofit Policy Executive

Oberstein is the executive director of Jewish World Watch, a nonprofit organization that advocates against genocide around the world. Oberstein served on the L.A. Ethics Commission between 2015 and 2018 and was president of the commission in 2018. She attempted to run for the District 12 City Council seat in 2019, but was not allowed because of a rule that said Ethics Commission members had to be off the commission for at least two years before running for office. She is married to Jeremy Oberstein, who previously served as chief of staff to former L.A. City Controller Ron Galperin.

Platform highlights:

  • On housing affordability: Oberstein wants to work with local churches to utilize the “Yes in God’s Backyard” law, which streamlines affordable housing production on land owned by religious groups. 
  • On pedestrian and cyclist safety: She advocates for a “full scale reimagining of Vision Zero” and more bike lanes and protected pedestrian paths in District 12.
  • On public safety: Oberstein says she wants to invest more in public safety by “putting resources back into the [L.A. Police] Department.” She also wants to expand LAPD’s Community Safety Partnership Bureau, a community policing program to improve relationships between police and community residents.
  • On restoring public trust: She supports ethics reforms, City Council expansion and an independent redistricting commission. Oberstein says L.A. needs to have an “empowered” Ethics Commission to restore confidence in government, and that the commission’s “staffing limitations and outdated policies” prevents it from being able to do its job fully. 

Go deeper: Jump to Oberstein's full answers to the LAist candidate survey

More voter resources:


Follow the money

Spending by committees outside the control of any candidate has far outpaced fundraising by the candidates themselves — and all of it is directed at the re-election of Councilmember John Lee.

The union representing L.A. police has spent more than $45,000 to oppose Serena Oberstein.

What questions do you have about the March 5 primary election?
Whether it's about how to interpret the results or track your ballot, we're here to help you understand the 2024 primary election on March 5.

In their own words

We gave both candidates the opportunity to speak directly to the voters and answer the following questions in no more than 300 words apiece:

  • The severe shortage of affordable housing is driving up homelessness. What would you prioritize in order to increase the supply?
  • Vision Zero — the effort to end pedestrian and cyclist fatalities — has been an abject failure. What specific steps would you take to reduce the number of fatalities among pedestrians and bicyclists?
  • What’s your top public safety issue and how would you address it?
  • L.A. city government has gone through a series of corruption scandals. What should be done to restore public trust?
  • What else should we know about your plans for the district?

On a lighter note, we also asked the candidates to share something surprising about themselves, something voters might find revealing .


John S. Lee

Your priorities to increase the affordable housing supply:

Rolling back the restrictions on small mom-and-pop property landlords. These property owners provide critical housing stock needed for Los Angeles. I have opposed policies that have disincentivized the creation and retention of affordable rental units.

Making streets safer for pedestrians, cyclists:

Coalition building and community buy-in is critical to reduce the number of fatalities among pedestrians and bicyclists. I have spent my entire 20-year career in public service bringing together Democrats, Republicans, Independents, labor, business owners and community activists to improve the quality of life in Council District 12.

One such example of coalition building is Metro’s North San Fernando Valley Transit Corridor Project, where I worked collaboratively over three years with agencies and stakeholders to build consensus around a revised project that will serve more riders across more diverse communities of the Valley, includes zero emission electric buses, provides improved bus stop design and shelter amenities, and is cost effective.

Public safety priorities:

We can’t achieve any of our goals without Los Angeles being a safe city. I voted against all arbitrary "defund the police" LAPD cuts and am committed to increasing the morale among our rank-and-file officers. I am proud to have the support of our city’s rank-and-file police officers and firefighters.

Restoring public trust:

Transparency with the public is the most effective way to root out corruption. I have always been open and honest with my community regarding my actions and positions. I believe it’s time that the city implements a redistricting process similar to the state and county’s independent redistricting commissions. An independent redistricting process will restore trust with the public.

Additional priorities for your district:

I will continue to build on my record of finding solutions to get people housed and keep our neighborhoods safe. When I first took office, Council District 12 had zero beds to help get people off the street. Today, we have over 200 beds, with well over 100 additional beds to come online by the end of my term. In light of the legal landscape the city is operating under, we need to have housing available in order to address the crisis on our streets. However, the homeless services I support include services to address the root causes of homelessness, such as mental health and addiction.

I will also continue CARE+ enhanced hygiene and street engagement services in Council District 12, a process that has been refined to prioritize the well-being and dignity of our unhoused neighbors.

A recent City Controller report shows that under my leadership, Council District 12 has the most enforcement of [Ordinance] 41.18 anti-camping zones near sensitive areas like interim and permanent housing, schools, daycare centers, and parks. While these efforts are outreach-led, I firmly believe that enforcement of these rules are necessary and show my commitment to keeping promises made to my community. Under my leadership, CD12 boasts the most robust enforcement in the entire city, working closely with LAPD to ensure our residents feel secure.The City needs a thriving local business community in order to provide core services. My parents’ small business provided everything for me and my brother growing up. I am proud of the support I have from both citywide business organizations and local CD12 business owners.

Tell us something surprising about yourself: 

I was an extra on an episode of the original Full House TV show .

Serena Oberstein

Your priorities to increase the affordable housing supply:

The housing affordability crisis is urgent and must be met with all the tools we have. I will:

1) Appoint a housing deputy for the 12th District to address the most pressing needs and interface with all agencies of government. This staff person will work with the Homeless and Housing Deputy in the Mayor’s Office, Housing and Community Investment Department Advocate, the county and state to coordinate and expedite getting resources. They will also interface with LAPD and social service agencies to ensure those who are in the most dire need get the care they need while protecting our stores and streets.

2) Partner with local churches and houses of worship to utilize the “Yes in God’s Backyard” law that rezoned land owned by nonprofit colleges and religious institutions, such as churches, mosques, and synagogues, to allow for affordable housing.

3) We must utilize vacant parcels of land, identified by [former] Controller Ron Galperin, to build cabin communities and permanent supportive housing. We should explore utilizing these parcels for workforce housing for those employed by the City, especially near government institutions.

Finally, the Sepulveda VA Hospital should be considered for Veteran housing. The VA hospital in West LA announced a plan this year to provide housing to 120 homeless veterans through a partnership with the Biden Administration. This could be a great way for CD12 to receive federal funding and address one of the most vulnerable unhoused communities.

Making streets safer for pedestrians, cyclists:

Our city needs to do everything it can to both encourage more multi-modal options of transportation and reduce pedestrian fatalities in Los Angeles, where numbers remain troublingly high. We need a full scale reimagining of Vision Zero to ensure we are doing our job of protecting Angelenos while increasing other forms of transportation.

To that end, we need to increase the number and safety of bike lanes, create drastically more protected pedestrian paths, and build systems of public transportation that talk to each other through partnerships with other cities and businesses. Sadly, that is not happening in CD12 even as the City works to address these paramount issues in other areas.

As part of its core mission, the L.A. Dept. of Transportation launched thousands of projects along its identified High-Injury Network, areas of the city that account for 70% of deaths and severe injuries for people walking. Of the thousands of projects launched by the city to increase safety at intersections, coordinate bus stop safety, and create more livable streets, just 26 have been completed in CD12, among the lowest of any Council district. Vision Zero has to be retooled as does our commitment to protecting pedestrians, cyclists and others throughout our community.

Public safety priorities:

Everyone deserves to feel safe in their homes and neighborhoods. Unfortunately, in too many communities of CD12, that is not the case. In my neighborhood, for example, LAPD’s Devonshire Division is reporting that incidents of robbery, rape, homicide, and burglary are all on the rise this year. There are a myriad of reasons why that may be the case, but it’s clear that we need to invest more in public safety, including in putting resources back into the department that can actually help sustain its long term vision of safer communities.

That includes having honest conversations with command staff on where we can best allocate sworn resources and civilian resources within the department. We also need to strengthen the Community Safety Partnership (CSP) Bureau so it exists in every division and community, instead of the 10 communities in which it currently exists. The CSP approach has to be more all hands on deck and not just a reactive approach to headlines.

I will also work with law enforcement and businesses to make sure our communities are protected from those experiencing mental health crises. Trained intervention workers from my office will be out each day — not behind a desk — with LAPD and social service agencies on speed dial to proactively help those in need while protecting our businesses and community.

Restoring public trust:

As a former Vice President and President of the LA City Ethics Commission, I worked on a single premise: How do we restore confidence in a system stained with corruption? That's one of the reasons I'm running for City Council, announcing my candidacy just weeks after the Ethics Commission accused Councilmember John Lee of “an array of governmental ethics violations,” actions that led to criminal charges and jail time for Lee’s former boss, the former councilmember serving this district, and included "...attempting to mislead the FBI and the U.S. attorney’s office.”

Ethics Commission audits trigger investigations into things like laundering, embezzlement, and misreporting, but the department lacks the ability to fully monitor its expansive portfolio given their staffing limitations and outdated policies. We shouldn’t have to wait for an FBI probe to restore faith in our democracy. We need bold action and real solutions. That starts with an empowered Ethics [Commission].

Additional priorities for your district:

I also support an independent redistricting commission to bring more transparency to our constitutionally mandated duty. This is a long overdue policy that will allow for community input and power to be more decentralized, which will lead to a more fair, open, and equitable process.

One more tool is increasing the size of the City Council to ensure we are meeting the needs of all constituents: 15 Councilmembers for 4 million Angelenos is simply too small to adequately meet the needs of all constituents.

Tell us something surprising about yourself:

When I’m not running for office, I like to train for endurance sports with Team in Training to raise money for the Leukemia Lymphoma Society that funds research and treatment to one day find a cure for a pervasive and brutal disease. Since 2008, I’ve run three half marathons, two marathons, and three triathlons. I’ve had a number of people in my life affected by leukemia, non-Hodgkin's and other forms of blood cancers.

By training for these types of events during the treatment of friends and family who are undergoing treatment for cancer or in memory of those lost with other people who are also navigating the illness or death of their loved ones, we’ve been able to turn a malady and a sense of powerlessness into a way to make progress and build communities of support.

More Voter Guides

City of Los Angeles

  • City Council: There are seven districts seats on this ballot: 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 and 14.
  • Healthy Streets LA: Take a closer look at Measure HLA, aimed at making streets safer for pedestrians and bicyclists — and holding the city accountable to do just that.

L.A. County

  • Board of Supervisors: There are three districts on this ballot: 2, 4 and 5.
  • District Attorney: Compare the 12 candidates running for District Attorney.
  • Los Angeles Unified School District: Here's an overview of the challenges facing the district. Plus: Meet the candidates vying to represent your child's education in districts 1, 3, 5 and 7.
  • The judiciary: There are more than two dozen judges up for election or reelection. Plus: Tips to make sure you're putting right person on the bench.
  • County Central Committees: There are nearly 200 seats up for election for these committees, which govern L.A.'s political parties.

Overwhelmed? We have some shortcuts for you.

Statewide races

  • Prop. 1: Evaluating a $6.38 billion bond proposition that aims to create more housing, treatment and support for people struggling with mental health, drug and alcohol issues. Plus: A guide to understanding California's Proposition system.

Federal races

Head to the Voter Game Plan homepage for the latest in election news.

Most Read